New idea for competition: Team Relay from 2x2 to 7x7
SimoneCiancottiP (2011-10-24 14:44:37 +0000)
Hello;
I want to propose a new official event to be added specifically to the races as the continental and world championships.
A relay race starting from the cube two by two and ending with a seven by seven cube, solving an order of magnitude the other four.
This race would be for nations and not only the various teams of friends.
Example for the United States.
2x2 Anthony Brooks
3x3 Rowe Hessler
4x4 Dan Cohen
5x5 Michael Gottlieb
6x6 Kevin Hays
7x7 Myles Casanas
Maybe you could also make a "Dream Team" of the best:
example
2x2 Cameron Stollery
3x3 Feliks Zemdegs
4x4 Giovanni Contardi
5x5 Dan Cohen
6x6 Kevin Hays
7x7 Michal Halckzuk
Obviously, according to members of the races you can make the team .. . So the day of the race and not too early
Thank you and sorry for my bad English
Ciancotti Simone Petrucci
Sebastien (2011-10-24 15:29:32 +0000)
Are you serious?!
This would surely be fun to have during an evening at worlds as unofficial event but your idea fails in qualifying as official event in so many ways that I won't even start listing some.
PS: Are you aware that this can of course be done at a competition (basically like everything else) without making it an unofficial event?
SimoneCiancottiP (2011-10-24 19:07:17 +0000)
Maybe I'll be an idiot, I always played sports like swimming and triathlon, and these things exist peacefully.
I can not see too much trouble to add this event among others.
Explain why you think it is a good thing
TMOY (2011-10-24 21:53:53 +0000)
Do you read the forums ? Reasons against relays being official have already be given a zillion times...
I'll give you only one: the lack of balance. In triathlon, the relative lengths of the three events have been carefully studied so that they are roughly of equal importance. In a 2-7 cube relay this is definitely not the case, the bigger the cube is the more important it is to get a good result, and the 2^3 is really negligible in comparison of the biggest ones. In your examples above, try to replace Anthony and Cameron by random noobs and you'll still get very fast teams.
Sebastien (2011-10-25 15:48:31 +0000)
Here what comes to my mind at first:
- how to measure? Times mostly > 10 minutes!
- team event -> unconvenient with database
- hard to organize during competitions (6 people around one timer?!)
- impossible to judge properly (proper transit from one puzzle to next puzzle?)
- hard to participate (as you need 5 other people for a team!)
- completely imballanced (as TMOY pointed out already)
- ....
I could surely find more arguments. I still can't believe you're seriously suggesting this as official event while this is so obviously a random fun event and while more reasonable events like MirrorBlocks, TeamBLD, etc. are already rejected.
BOSSCUBER (2015-04-28 11:54:40 +0000)
USA team:
2x2: Lucas Etter
3x3: Collin Burns
4x4: Kevin Costello III
5x5: Kevin Hays
6x6: Kevin Hays
7x7: Kevin Hays
Dream Team:
2x2: Lucas Etter
3x3: Feliks Zemdegs
4x4: Sebastian Weyer
5x5: Feliks Zemdegs
6x6: Kevin Hays
7x7: Mattia Furlan